Same-Day Appointments AvailableCall (605) 376-2130
Get Free QuoteCall (605) 376-2130

AGM vs Regular Car Battery: Which One Does Your Car Need?

If your car came with an AGM battery, it needs an AGM. If it came with a regular battery, a regular one is fine and an AGM is an optional upgrade.

Direct Brakes mobile service van parked behind a customer car on a Sioux Falls street
Quick Answer

If your car came with an AGM battery, it needs an AGM battery. Most cars with start-stop, the feature that shuts the engine off at red lights, use an AGM or a similar EFB battery. A regular flooded battery in one of those cars can fail within months and the start-stop system may stop working. If your car came with a regular battery, a regular one is fine, and an AGM is an optional upgrade that starts better in the cold and handles short trips and heavy electrical loads better. Installed, a regular battery runs $319 to $339 and an AGM runs $365 to $389, plus tax.

What Is an AGM Battery?

AGM stands for absorbed glass mat. Inside a regular battery, the plates sit in liquid acid. Inside an AGM, thin fiberglass mats soak up the acid and are packed tight against the plates. Nothing sloshes around, so the battery is spill proof, holds up better to vibration and can be drained and recharged many more times before it wears out.

A regular battery is also called a flooded or wet cell battery. It is the older, simpler design and still the right choice for many cars without start-stop.

AGM vs Regular Battery at a Glance

RegularAGM
Installed price$319 to $339$365 to $389
Start-stop carsNoYes
Cold weather startingGoodBetter
Handles deep drainsPoorlyBetter
Recharge speedSlowerFaster
Spill proofNoYes

Prices are Direct Brakes installed prices, plus tax, including installation at your location and recycling of the old battery.

Direct Brakes van with the doors open next to a customer car with the hood up at a Sioux Falls apartment lot
We bring the battery to you and install it in the parking lot.

Why Start-Stop Cars Need an AGM

Start-stop shuts the engine off when you stop and restarts it when you lift off the brake. While the engine is off, the battery runs the radio, the lights, the fans and the computers by itself. Then it has to crank the engine again, sometimes dozens of times on one drive across town.

A regular battery is not built for that. Battery maker Banner warns that a regular battery in a start-stop car can be defective within a few months, and that the start-stop system may stop working with the wrong battery. Some start-stop cars use an EFB, or enhanced flooded battery, which sits between the two. If your car came with an EFB, replace it with an EFB or an AGM. Never go down to a regular battery.

How to Tell Which Battery Your Car Has

Or give us the year, make and model and we will look it up for you.

Not Sure Which Battery You Need?

Tell us the year, make and model and we will match the right battery and bring it to you in Sioux Falls, Brandon, Tea and Harrisburg.

Get Free Estimate

Can You Switch Between AGM and Regular?

AGM to regular: no. If the car came with an AGM, it needs an AGM.

Regular to AGM: usually yes, as long as the size fits. It is a common upgrade for cars that sit a lot, make lots of short trips or run extra accessories.

Many European cars also need the new battery registered with the car's computer, and some need it coded if the type or size changes. Skip that step and the car can overcharge or undercharge the new battery. See BMW battery registration and the Mercedes auxiliary battery for how that works on those cars.

Is an AGM Battery Worth It?

If your car needs one, it is not optional. If your car came with a regular battery, an AGM is worth the extra cost when:

If you drive an older car without start-stop and most of your miles are longer drives, a quality regular battery will serve you well for less money.

What It Costs

We install DieHard batteries: Silver and Gold in the regular line and Platinum AGM. Regular batteries run $319 to $339 plus tax. AGM batteries run $365 to $389 plus tax depending on size. Both include installation at your location, a charging system test and recycling of the old battery. Registration or coding on European cars is included. Get your exact battery price in about a minute.

Frequently Asked Questions

A regular battery, also called flooded, holds liquid acid between its plates. An AGM battery holds the acid in fiberglass mats packed against the plates. That makes an AGM spill proof, better at handling deep drains and repeated restarts, and quicker to recharge. It also costs more.

If it came with one, yes. Look for AGM on the label of the battery in the car now. Most cars with start-stop use an AGM, and many European cars use one even without start-stop. If your car came with a regular battery, a regular one is fine.

No. A regular battery cannot handle the constant restarts and electrical load in a car built for an AGM. It can fail within months, and the start-stop system may stop working.

Usually yes, as long as the size fits. Some cars with a battery management system, including many European models, need the new battery registered or coded so the car charges it correctly.

With Direct Brakes, AGM batteries run $365 to $389 plus tax depending on size, installed at your location. Registration or coding on European cars is included. Regular batteries run $319 to $339 plus tax.

Same-Day Mobile Service

The Right Battery, Installed Where You Are

We match the correct AGM or regular battery to your vehicle, install it at your home or work, and handle the registration or coding European cars need.

Get Your Free Estimate

Or call (605) 376-2130 for same-day service